Thanks for posting this build thread. I’m new and am researching a rig with the Z71 high on my list. I was leaning toward the Ford at first, but it’s really a toss up until I go out and test drive them. I was a little concerned about the automatic locking rear, but it sounds like you prefer this. Clearance issues were second for me but I’m not sure how much I’ll actually need for my trips. I’m also considering a used ZR2 as well.
Sounds like you are having a hard time choosing and I cannot blame you. It really is a massive candy story out there right now and we are the excited kids! lol
I do wish that they would do all of these tests with say 800lbs in the bed. Typically a trucks suspension settles down and everything changes once you get a load in it(some trucks get way better and some trucks get way worse). Which is really important for us overlanders. Usually if you hear a reviewer stating how "harsh" a truck suspension is... then the following is what I hear in my mind. "This truck suspension is tuned more for work than the other trucks". Usually the harsh riding ones ride the best when under heavy load. Which may be an awesome thing for an overlander who can actually load up a vehicle with protection and gear without needing to change the suspension.
I once had over 1k lbs in the back of my old 05' Chevy Colorado. That thing went from having a pretty harsh ride... to riding like a Cadillac! It even handled better in corners! Who would have thought. It was built for work. (Something that "professional reviewers" usually forget about/forget to test).
One way to possibly narrow down your final pick is to make a list of needs and a list of wants. Prioritize what is most important/useful on a daily basis. That may help a good bit. I for instance prioritized the following
-Truck Bed required
-Driver seat adjustability/comfort (My back is going bad and I commute for 2.5hrs total every day) The Z71 seat adjusts high off of the floor, has lumbar adjust, and the steering wheel telescopes a long ways from the dash (which REALLY helps on those 8hr trip days!).
-Large Rear Cab for the 2 kids in car seats
-Decent fuel economy
-Can handle 800 to 1000lbs of weight in the bed, plus armor, Plus my family of 4
-True 4wd with at least a rear locker
-Good fuel range
As for the Ranger's weird folding rear seat... I would not care. I have car seats in mine. AKA they never get folded. If I just had dog or something I would like the other two trucks better. I do like the Colorado's bed most because it is so deep/more storage room. Downside is that the rear shocks had to be moved/lowered to keep the flex high when off-road.
I would still look at the Ranger if I were you. I bet it will be a great truck as long as it meets your needs. All three of them handled that trail without a problem. I would not be worried too much about ground clearance since they are all pretty close. The Tacoma and the Colorado have aftermarket skid options available already to where you can cover
everything with armor. I would add armor before making suspension adjustments anyways. If you have not noticed yet most folks do suspension first... then add everything to their vehicles... then have to do the suspension again. That is a huge waste/mistake IMHO.