This thread has really brought to the front, a few brands, that seem to fall right in line with the BFG's for perceived, if not actual toughness. They all now have a 3 ply sidewall's as far as I know. Thanks to BFG forcing the market to respond in kind. For most of us that have to budget for new tires, the question is not always what we want, but what we can afford. That does not mean just settling for OKAY, but getting the best we can afford with the most checked boxes we can get for a certain price point and performance. The WILDPEAKS seem to be a very popular alternative. They get good reviews from OB members, outside users, and off-road magazine tests on them. Another is those new PATAGONIA MT's, that with the exception of 1 OB member, have been immensely popular with users over a wide variety of vehicles. Their only shortcoming so far, is their newness on the market and no snow evaluations yet. A remedy i expect will be shortly forthcoming as winter approaches in the next couple of months.
No tire is bulletproof, and the shortcomings 1 driver had with 3 flats on new tires can be either bad luck, or driver error. In the case referenced, I will go with driver error because only 1 driver had this problem, and the difference between a puncture or not, could or maybe, was the line he took, compared to the others. The KM3's have been out now a while and if it was a construction manufacture problem, many others by now would have chimed in on it.
Personally I am probably done with BFG's, mostly because of their price point. I have posted my short comings with them, that being HEAT-CHECKING on all the sets i bought, way before their tread life was over. The hot desert asphalt just does not seem compatible on a DD, with the rubber compound they use, which see varied use on and off-road. Doing the TOYO AT's right now.....mixed reviews by OB members, and will see how they perform over their tread life. By then, I expect a few more Brands or Styles will be at the forefront of popular offerings on the market. The tire competition has made the manufacturers really have to step up their game, if they want to be competitive.
On a final note, if and when my next set becomes needed, I will really give the Patagonia MT's a close look,.......IF THEY STAY AT THE PRICE RANGE THEY ARE CURRENTLY AT. I do not do the miles I once did, so a softer tire with a slightly less mileage expectation, is a good trade-off, for the future vs their unexpecectedly positive good trail and road manners.