In general I agree, social media is twisting overlanding into something completely different from what it really is. I've viewed a number of these videos and have to seriously wonder if they really know what Overlanding is or does they desire for fame and glory overwhelm what they do. The first that comes to mind was entitled "The ultimate overland rig". It was some old Dodge pickup with a bunch of camping gear thrown in the bed. It may be his ultimate rig but I wouldn't say the title applies to everyone. The latest was "What makes Overland Expo great". After five minutes of watching people come up to this person saying "I am your biggest fan . . . " I shut it off. That may be what is great about Expo for you but many others would disagree. With all of these videos I have to ask, what are you doing that is overlanding? With all the talk about yourself, your gear, and your rig, where is the exploring? With 4, 5 or 8 hours a day dedicated to video editing, and the associated time finding a WiFi spot and up loading, how much are you really exploring?
But its not just Facebook, Instagram, or even Youtube, its also forums. I had one guy tell me he has been an overlander for 20 years because he goes to the same National Forest, camps in the same campsite, and wheels on the same trails each of those 20 years. When we first learned about Overland Journal and Overlanding, we saw the foundation of Overlanding was Explore. We had done the camping thing, the travel, and the off roading, but we didn't go into this saying we already do this. We went in to this saying we are new and need to learn what it is. I have heard few people in forums say that so I have to wonder if they really know what Overlanding is. Over the years we continue to learn about Overlanding, finding out about other Overlanders, and refining our version of Overlanding. What we have learned from other Overlanders is;
1. What road, trail, or path you take is determined by what you want to explore. If you watch people like Expedition Overland, 80 to 90 percent of what they drive on is paved roads. Yes, remote locations normally means driving on dirt but driving on pavement does not exclude someone as an Overlander. Hell, when was the last time you got out of your vehicle and walked through the woods to see something?
2. Camping doesn't make it Overlanding. Every single Overlander I have heard, seen, or read about has stayed in a hotel. Some are out of necessity, no camping available in the area, or severe weather, or for personal security. Some stay simply out of desire, hot shower. I've seen in forums where people try to say staying in an established campgrounds is not Overlanding. Bull.
3. Exploring the people of an area is an important part of Overlanding. I am sure most everyone in this forum has seen the Expedition Overland videos. How many towns did they stop in and talk to the people, explore the town, and learn about its history? That isn't just an Expedition Overland thing, most of the top end Overlanders make a point of stopping in towns and meeting people. Most of them say the best way to learn about an area is through the food. Adventure is about getting out of your comfort zone. The best way to get out of your comfort zone is to meet someone who you don't know, who is different from you, who has a different view of the world, and eats different foods than you.
One of the few video series I like to watch is Andrew White (4xOverland). In one video he talks about the pros and cons of forums, pointing out there is a lot of experienced people in them with good information but there are also a lot of self appointed experts who provide information that only leads to failure. These are also the same people who try to twist what Overlanding is to mean only what they do. Its not a new thing, they are in almost every forum. In the Jeep community it started out years ago with "its not a real Jeep if it has square headlights". Now they have gotten all the way down to which color determines what a real Jeep is. "You are not a true Overlander if . . . " If you read this in a posting, run!
For anyone new to Overlanding the first question is always, what is Overlanding. Its an individual thing to start with so its meaning is largely up to you. Overlanding, originally termed Touring in South Africa, is "vehicle dependent travel to remote locations where the journey is the destination". Vague, yes. Its so vague that it would include the old retired couple in a Class A visiting Russel Cave National Monument to the prepper looking for a new place to hide in the woods. A global Overlander on a three year expedition is just as much an Overlander as the young couple in a Kia Soul on an overnight to the nearest National Forest. Who determines who is an Overlander or what makes it Overlanding? No One. The problem with forums is we have too many self appointed experts who seem to think they are the governing body of the hobby, and their self glorification is far more important than the hobby.
The biggest thing I have seen on Overland forums is people saying, when they claim to be an Overlander, that they have been doing this for years. If your idea of adventure is only wheeling in some forest or camping in some woods, always far from other people, that's all well and good. The problem, just as with new Overlanders watching the Youtube glory seekers, starts when these people push their view of Overlanding and the newbies get a distorted opinion of what Overlanding really is. Some people in the forums are just as bad as the Youtube glory seekers, spreading their limited view of Overlanding like the gospel Some even go as far as saying they are so disgusted with the present state of Overlanding that they no longer call them self an Overlander (as if they are above everyone else in the hobby).
Advise to the newbies; As with everything, there are some good people on the forums that do provide good information and who honestly want to help new people. Take the time to find them.