A winch is nice, knowing how to properly use it is even better.
Tire, winch, and lockers are my top three suggestions for upgrades in that order. I seldom recommend lifts. I have had three lifted rigs, and only one of those three handled as well as stock.
larger tires is going to lift your differential and transfer case more than a lift kit. The lift kit does nothing for raising the differentials at all without adding larger tires.
The winch second for recovering others along with the ability to recover your self. I personally have used my winch far more to recover other people than recovering my self or clearing a trail.
Lockers last, because with lockers you will make you feel over qualified to go places you probably shouldn’t and will need the larger tires and winch you already installed.
now, since your rig already has a lift, larger tires, and a rtt, adding a winch for a piece of mind might be an option. Ask yourself how many times you have actually gotten stuck so bad a winch was required vs a tug from someone else.
I have been doing this quite some time, and have gotten stuck more times than I care to admit. I have only been stuck twice where a winch was the only option. Both times having my own winch wouldn’t have made the situation any less sticky. Both times the best method of pulling me out was by pulling backwards. Both times I was high centered by my front and rear bumpers blocking the path for a frontal recovery, think creek crossing, and being pulled frontwards would have destroyed the creek bed.
I mention this because even though I have a winch now, only once it was used for self recovery, and even then there were other things I could have done to get unstuck. The rest of the time I have used it to safely recover other rigs and to clear trails.
The one piece of recovery gear I always felt missing in my kit was the farm jack. I don’t want to get into that debate, but it was a tool in my grandparents kit, my dads kit, and my first kit that got stolen. It is a tool that my brother and I learned how to safely use as young kids, learned to respect, and most important how useful it is as a tool other than just a jack... although the jack part of it is nice too.
@Dave K and
@PNW EXPLR great advice