I have been using an REI 3 person Dome for about 20 years or so, it looks very similar in looks the 3rd tent in this picture without the fly. It has been all sorts of places with me, and in all sorts of conditions. Rain, Hurricane Hugo residual winds in New Mexico, Alaskan and Pacific NW rain for a week at a time, Sandy beaches, desert sand and heat ... name it.. it has been an excellent value. I had to reseal the seams a few years back on a flooded river rafting trip, always use a footprint and the fly. I still love it and it keeps on ticking, believe it or not, it still looks almost new baring some faded color. Just a few weeks ago I found a lightly used OzTent on craigslist.. going to give it a go for overlanding and see how that works out. I do have to say the Oz is not cheap, is friggen heavy and has absolutely nothing going for it in the packed up department. But set up it seems pretty dang neat.
--
Rick