Here are the tasting notes from my recent trip. I made them for my own future reference, so they're 100% my personal opinion. As an overall brand, Patagonia was the best and most consistent.
Peak Refuel Homestyle Chicken and Rice: Very filling. OK taste (6 of 10). Needed longer to rehydrate at 6700 feet. Maybe a little more water. Definitely needed added spice.
Mountain House Scrambled Eggs with Bacon: Maybe better left raw. More like popcorn. Needed longer to hydrate at 6700 feet. Flavor decent (5). Needs Cholula.
Trailtopia Jambalaya: Winner! Excellent flavor (8). Very spicy! Add 50% more rehydration time at altitude. Single size more than enough.
Peak Refuel Beef Chili Mac: Horrible! Like seriously, was something wrong at the factory that day? The only flavor note was smoked chili powder. No amount of Cholula could save this. (2) On the “never again” list.
Trailtopia Beef Stew: Pretty good (7). Added salt, pepper, and cumin. Large portions, easily enough for two, maybe with some added mashed potatoes.
Patagonia Savory Grains (Green Kale + Kamut) and Lemon Caper Mackerel: Excellent! (8) Would even eat at home. Healthiest meal of the trip. Cholula helped. Hearty meal for one, OK for two with something else. Downside is it needs an external container to rehydrate.
Peak Refuel Sweet Pork and Rice: Very good! (9) Just a little sweet for my taste, but really well done. Big chunks of pork. Generous serving. Even a little heat to it. No need to add spices.
Trailtopia Egg Scramble: Did not use. Requires cooking in a nonstick pan, so f**k ‘em. UPDATE: Cooked this up at the cabin and it actually isn't too bad (6). I would consider it if I was planning to do some actual cooking, but if then...why not just bring eggs, ham, etc. and scramble it myself?
Mountain House Pro-Pak Chili Mac: Pretty good flavor (7). Would include again. Cholula helped. Consider adding nutritional yeast flakes for a cheesy note.
Mountain House Chicken and Rice: Decidedly meh (5). Nothing offensive, but not much flavor, either.
Good-To-Go Kale and White Bean Stew: Quite good (8). Huge portion, too much for one person. Needed a little bit of salt and some nutritional yeast flakes.
Tasty Bite Jasmin Rice, Chana Masala, and Lentils: All very tasty (7). Requires dirtying multiple pots, so not ideal for camping. Also, for one, needed to store open bag of rice. OK with cooler.