In October I bought a 2019 Colorado ZR2 3.6L (gas) with the Bison package after fifteen years and nearly four hundred thousand miles on two Tacoma’s; 05 (195K) and 12 (180K). Both were four wheel drive, double cab, TRD Off-Road, 4.0L and autos. At least a fourth of the miles were logged while towing a 19’ Scamp ‘fifth’ wheel weighing 3,500#’s around the country. The Tacoma’s were solid and capable trucks but, when I comparison shopped this time, it is my opinion the other mfrs had caught and, in many areas surpassed Toyota.
The Tacoma’s were relatively trouble free but I didn’t find them to be anything special in this regard. My 00 TJ, 08 Solstice and 98 Montero have been just as good with the Mitsubishi being the most trouble free vehicle I’ve ever owned.
As to resale, Tacoma definitely has the best reputation but comparing similarity equipped 2015 and later Tacoma’s and Colorado’s on Kelly Blue Book doesn’t really support this, especially if you look at the delta in initial cost.
Toyota switched from the 4.0l to a 3.5L V6 a few years back and I don’t think you’ll find a lot of even diehard Tacoma fans who think this was an improvement. Horsepower and torque ratings are similar but at a much higher RPM for the newer engine and a test drive convinced me it would have problems with the camper regardless of tow ratings. So far, the ZR2 has proven to be a much better tow vehicle with lots more power than the Tacoma. Towing mpg was 11-13 and is now 15-17. Range is improved with the better mileage and larger tank.
The ZR2 comes well equipped for off-roading in stock form with beefed up axles and lockers front AND rear. The DSSV shocks are simply amazing at speed in the back country. The Bison package adds armor on both ends and underneath. Off the dealer lot, I thinks it’s more capable than the TRD PRO but I’m also sure there are aftermarket options for the PRO that could easily change this. This week, Chevy announced factory support for a Calloway supercharger (410 HP) on the Colorado and for an enhanced Bison package from AEV that would include 4,10 gears. That indicates a high degree of commitment to me.
Al