Satellite Communicator--Which is Best Deal?

  • HTML tutorial
DanW

DanW

Rank V
Launch Member

Member III

2,268
Danville, Indiana
Member #

13615

I've used a Garmin (Older Delorme) Inreach and had a decent experience with it. It has since broken down and I'm looking to get a new one. But I see Spot and Zoleo as competitors.

I'm wondering which is the best bang for the buck. In other words, it works as it should, but costs the least. If it doesn't work as it should, I wouldn't want it for any savings.

What would I expect from Spot or Zoleo for a plan that includes some texting (doesn't have to be a lot) and map tracking? I used to buy insurance with the Garmin, as well, and found it reasonable. It was something like $25 for a year with $50k coverage per incident with up to 2 incidents ($100k total). That includes rescue and hospitalization, etc.

The insurance is not a big consideration. The activation fee and monthly fee are what I'm more interested in. With the Garmin I had a plan that updated location every 10 minutes, if I recall correctly.

I found a refurbished Inreach Mini for $250. The Zoleo is $199. That's the cheapest of them for the hardware, anyway.

Any shared experiences are appreciated!
 
DanW

DanW

Rank V
Launch Member

Member III

2,268
Danville, Indiana
Member #

13615

zgfiredude said:
I have a Zoleo. I like it a lot, it works, the plan is reasonable, and it's not a Garmin product. That's all I want/need.
Click to expand...
It looks like the interface is very simple. The Garmin can be complicated with sending texts. I had some troubles with it from time to time.
 
Z

zgfiredude

Rank VI

Steward I

3,953
Silt, CO, USA
First Name
Brian
Last Name
Nichols
Member #

28938

Service Branch
Firefighter
I will admit that I am not a Garmin fan...having owned several and NEVER really working well with any of them.

Zoleo is refreshing!
 
reaver

reaver

Rank VI
Member

Explorer I

3,680
Caldwell, ID, USA
First Name
Brian
Last Name
McGahuey
Member #

23711

Ham/GMRS Callsign
GMRS WRMV941
I have the zoleo. It works great. I bought it based on the recommendation of a friend of mine who has one. Honestly, I feel like the biggest advantage of the zoleo vs the inreach is that zoleo gives you a dedicated number that doesn't change, so people can text it, just like a cell phone.

Also, the hardware periodically goes on sale for 150, if you're willing to wait to catch it on sale. It usually happens sometime in December.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zgfiredude, DanW and K12
Rolando

Rolando

Rank V
Launch Member

Member III

2,796
Lovettsville, VA
First Name
Roland
Last Name
Woldt
Member #

15186

I just bought the Motorola Defy for the same reason - you can use it like an app on your phone. I don't foresee a situation where I won't have my phone near (and both need to be charged as well...).
 
  • Like
Reactions: DanW
KonzaLander

KonzaLander

Rank VI
Member

Traveler II

3,402
Junction City, Kansas, USA
Member #

15814

Ham/GMRS Callsign
KE0EBF
I am curious about the texting complication you have had with the Garmin/Delorme. It's pretty straight forward in the Earthmate app.

For what it's worth, I am still using an old yellow Delorme InReach SE. It just works and still has a phenomenal battery life, even when tracking. Garmin still hasn't managed to screw up the InReach system since they acquired it... yet... I would be cautious in buying a new Garmin device without fully vetting it. Have you considered buying a second hand Delorme InReach?
 
DanW

DanW

Rank V
Launch Member

Member III

2,268
Danville, Indiana
Member #

13615

KonzaLander said:
I am curious about the texting complication you have had with the Garmin/Delorme. It's pretty straight forward in the Earthmate app.

For what it's worth, I am still using an old yellow Delorme InReach SE. It just works and still has a phenomenal battery life, even when tracking. Garmin still hasn't managed to screw up the InReach system since they acquired it... yet... I would be cautious in buying a new Garmin device without fully vetting it. Have you considered buying a second hand Delorme InReach?
Click to expand...
A number of times I had sent texts, they were not received. Even though they appeared to successfully go through.

Yep, I certainly have thought of another Delorme.
 
DRAX

DRAX

Rank V
Member

Advocate I

1,451
Monticello, IL
First Name
Hogan
Last Name
Whittall
Member #

28590

Ham/GMRS Callsign
W9DRX
Rolando said:
I just bought the Motorola Defy for the same reason - you can use it like an app on your phone. I don't foresee a situation where I won't have my phone near (and both need to be charged as well...).
Click to expand...
I looked into the Defy but it was a hard pass (I have the Zoleo and wife has an inReach so wasn't serious anyway, but always curious about new products), aside from SOS and pre-programmed check-in messages you can only communicate with other Bullitt Messenger users, there is no 2-way communication via SMS to non-Bullitt users. With the Zoleo and inReach your device is assigned an actual number that can send/receive SMS messages to/from any cell phone, you're not limited to only talking to other specific app users.

Since my wife has the inReach Mini and I have the Zoleo I've had a chance to compare and contrast both. Personally, I find the Zoleo plan more reasonable and a closer fit to how I use it, the Garmin plans don't offer as much value, IMO. The Zoleo is bigger than an inReach Mini but the battery lasts much longer. I have my Zoleo mounted to a dash rail where it charges whenever my truck is on, it can be used while in the mount, and is easily popped out to carry it.

20220728_163436.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: wigsajumper, DanW, John Bishop and 1 other person
Rolando

Rolando

Rank V
Launch Member

Member III

2,796
Lovettsville, VA
First Name
Roland
Last Name
Woldt
Member #

15186

DRAX said:
I looked into the Defy but it was a hard pass (I have the Zoleo and wife has an inReach so wasn't serious anyway, but always curious about new products), aside from SOS and pre-programmed check-in messages you can only communicate with other Bullitt Messenger users, there is no 2-way communication via SMS to non-Bullitt users. With the Zoleo and inReach your device is assigned an actual number that can send/receive SMS messages to/from any cell phone, you're not limited to only talking to other specific app users.

Since my wife has the inReach Mini and I have the Zoleo I've had a chance to compare and contrast both. Personally, I find the Zoleo plan more reasonable and a closer fit to how I use it, the Garmin plans don't offer as much value, IMO. The Zoleo is bigger than an inReach Mini but the battery lasts much longer. I have my Zoleo mounted to a dash rail where it charges whenever my truck is on, it can be used while in the mount, and is easily popped out to carry it.

View attachment 266886
Click to expand...
I hear you. But when you send a message to a regular phone number it includes a link to that app, so that the recipient can reply. I am sure that in a case of emergency everyone, and in the case of your regular contacts (spouse, etc.) they will have the app already downloaded.

The benefit of this is -to turn your argument around that you just have one cell number and someone doesn't send a reply accidentally to a different number (the one you typically use).

Bit either way, it is good to have an option to stay in contact with someone when you lose cell reception - independent of the tool (and varying costs).
 
  • Like
Reactions: DanW
rtexpeditions

rtexpeditions

Rank V
Launch Member

Advocate II

2,315
Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
First Name
Randall
Last Name
Treloyn
Member #

5615

Ham/GMRS Callsign
VK7VWK
I have a Garmin Montana 700i.
It has a much better interface than the smaller InReach's, almost like using a standard mobile with a touchscreen and familiar keyboard interface.
Although it doesn't have a consistent phone number, those who need to reach me can enter the Garmin email into the texting screen of their phones.
I bought it for its navigation as well and the screen is big enough for my ageing eyes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DanW
Ebbs

Ebbs

Rank VI
Member

Influencer III

4,518
Spokane, WA, USA
First Name
Brandon
Last Name
Eberhardt
Member #

20143

Ham/GMRS Callsign
KE0JBH
Service Branch
Air Force 02-18
I hadn't really looked into the Zoleo before... definitely peaked my interest.... I notice inreach says the SMS are 160 character max... but Zoleo doen't mention a max anywhere... anyone with real world experience speak to any sort of limit?
 
  • Like
Reactions: PapaDave
DRAX

DRAX

Rank V
Member

Advocate I

1,451
Monticello, IL
First Name
Hogan
Last Name
Whittall
Member #

28590

Ham/GMRS Callsign
W9DRX
Ebbs said:
I hadn't really looked into the Zoleo before... definitely peaked my interest.... I notice inreach says the SMS are 160 character max... but Zoleo doen't mention a max anywhere... anyone with real world experience speak to any sort of limit?
Click to expand...
From ZOLEO Mobile Messaging App

*Characters supported: SMS/text up to 160, email up to 200, app-to-app 900+.
Click to expand...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ebbs
DRAX

DRAX

Rank V
Member

Advocate I

1,451
Monticello, IL
First Name
Hogan
Last Name
Whittall
Member #

28590

Ham/GMRS Callsign
W9DRX
Ebbs said:
ok thanks. I apparently didn't follow the link to the app info.
Click to expand...
No worries, I couldn't remember what the limits were so figured I might as well share the official info as a reference. Wasn't meaning for it to come across as RTFM-ish. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: PapaDave and Ebbs
Ebbs

Ebbs

Rank VI
Member

Influencer III

4,518
Spokane, WA, USA
First Name
Brandon
Last Name
Eberhardt
Member #

20143

Ham/GMRS Callsign
KE0JBH
Service Branch
Air Force 02-18
DRAX said:
No worries, I couldn't remember what the limits were so figured I might as well share the official info as a reference. Wasn't meaning for it to come across as RTFM-ish. :D
Click to expand...
oh you didn't at all, very much appreciated it!
 
  • Like
Reactions: DRAX
PapaDave

PapaDave

Local Expert Northern ID and North East WA
Member

Protector II

8,868
Coeur d'Alene, ID, USA
First Name
Dave
Last Name
Addington
Member #

10123

Ham/GMRS Callsign
KN6BKH
Ebbs said:
DRAX said:
No worries, I couldn't remember what the limits were so figured I might as well share the official info as a reference. Wasn't meaning for it to come across as RTFM-ish. :D
Click to expand...
oh you didn't at all, very much appreciated it!
Click to expand...
I would have been Brandon if it was me. Read Brandon read! Haha jk
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Ebbs and DRAX
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom