Rubber Clamp Long Term Review

  • HTML tutorial

Masheen365

Rank IV
Launch Member

Advocate II

1,018
South GA
Member #

1866

Disclamer: These clamps aren't on my vehicle. They are installed on a fire engine that has seen 4 years of service at a full-time career department. The clamps get used almost daily, so compared to what you will see, this is EXTREME use.

So we were cleaning the engine today and I decided to snap a few pictures of where these rubber clamps have failed or are starting to fail. I thought it might help some folks see where and how they fail. I will say, it seems that user error and rough use contribute to the failures the most. 20170721_100314.jpg
As you can see, the pull tap broke off. This clamp holds a plastic shovel that we use on motor vehicle collisions to scoop up oil dry and debris. It get used nearly daily, so this particular clamp saw a lot of use before it failed. Nearly 3 years for this one. Again, heavy handed fire fighters broke this from over tightening it time and time again.

20170721_100339.jpg
This one is one of two clamps that held a large pair of bolt cutters (~36"). The first one had all 4 screws slip through and was lost. This one was over tightened until it about pinched through again. This is why you need to be careful not to over tighten or put too heavy of an object in the clamp. I believe the heavy bolt cutters were too much for these small clamps and pulled them off the screws. Bigger screw heads may have helped too.

I hope this can sort of help, I know there are a lot of these holding shovels and the like on rigs. They are great when they are used properly. Don't over tighten, and don't over load them and you should be in good shape.
 

Albacore

Rank 0

Traveler I

60
US
Thanks for the review. As a FF myself I know we can be rough on stuff, especially truckies [emoji6]. I don't like using a screw at the corners just for the reason you show in the pic. There doesn't seem to be enough material. I put a bolt and nut through the center hole and it seems more secure. Overall, your experiences with these clamps give me more peace of mind with my limited use. Thank you.

Sent from my SM-G920P using Tapatalk
 

Masheen365

Rank IV
Launch Member

Advocate II

1,018
South GA
Member #

1866

I don't like using a screw at the corners just for the reason you show in the pic. There doesn't seem to be enough material. I put a bolt and nut through the center hole and it seems more secure
Agreed, the ones we have like that have no signs of stress.
20170724_080423.jpg
This onebdoesnt support much weight. It stabilizes an axe handle which has the head supported by a tray.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Albacore

Red Beard

Rank V
Launch Member

Traveler I

1,836
Mexia, Texas
Member #

6543

Really not trying to hi-jack your thread here. I highly recommend PAC tool mounts. I was introduced to them through work and they are tough as nails. We mount them on all of our tracked equipment to hold a sharp shooter to clean the tracks with. They get the crap beat out of them in the woods during prestripping operations and still hold up.

AF97BCEF-18B9-4A30-92EC-016D73AC5233-28325-00001E29E1A85C47.jpeg
http://www.thefirestore.com/store/product.aspx/productId/11733/selectedVariationId/134001/PAC-Tool-Handlelok-Mounting-Bracket?utm_source=google&utm_campaign=google&utm_content=134001&utm_medium=cpc&gclid=CjwKCAjwtdbLBRALEiwAm8pA5dWkw_lHHCSoGjQtsGTwjDWAr5ds-M55TDyDdMF523coYDbHnbnjTBoCjWUQAvD_BwE
 

adventure_is_necessary

Rocky Mountain Region Local Expert Kansas
Member

Traveler III

4,007
Bonner Springs, Kansas, United States
First Name
Lucas
Last Name
Antes
Member #

7082

Ham/GMRS Callsign
KE0ZXA
Disclamer: These clamps aren't on my vehicle. They are installed on a fire engine that has seen 4 years of service at a full-time career department. The clamps get used almost daily, so compared to what you will see, this is EXTREME use.

So we were cleaning the engine today and I decided to snap a few pictures of where these rubber clamps have failed or are starting to fail. I thought it might help some folks see where and how they fail. I will say, it seems that user error and rough use contribute to the failures the most. View attachment 29730
As you can see, the pull tap broke off. This clamp holds a plastic shovel that we use on motor vehicle collisions to scoop up oil dry and debris. It get used nearly daily, so this particular clamp saw a lot of use before it failed. Nearly 3 years for this one. Again, heavy handed fire fighters broke this from over tightening it time and time again.

View attachment 29731
This one is one of two clamps that held a large pair of bolt cutters (~36"). The first one had all 4 screws slip through and was lost. This one was over tightened until it about pinched through again. This is why you need to be careful not to over tighten or put too heavy of an object in the clamp. I believe the heavy bolt cutters were too much for these small clamps and pulled them off the screws. Bigger screw heads may have helped too.

I hope this can sort of help, I know there are a lot of these holding shovels and the like on rigs. They are great when they are used properly. Don't over tighten, and don't over load them and you should be in good shape.

I've got these in my Amazon wishlist to hold an axe, shovel, and possibly more down the road. Glad to have a review on them! Thanks!!!!
 

Jeepney

Rank IV

Pathfinder I

1,212
MN
I use it to hold light items like a shovel and fishing poles. Definitely useful.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

britz

Rank VI
Launch Member

Off-Road Ranger I

3,089
Musselshell, Idaho
Member #

5767

Ham/GMRS Callsign
K6YTI
Great post. I've got a tender parked outside of the cabin with Quikfists holding many of the handtools. Looks like i'm giving her a good once over on the clamps this morning, I'm not sure when they were installed.